How Hiring Leaders Can Ask Better Questions to Improve Hiring Outcomes

Hiring decisions shape the future of organizations. Yet too often, great candidates are overlooked—not because they lack the skills, but because the right questions weren’t asked. Many candidates report being rejected for not having experience in areas like change management or process implementation, even though those topics never came up during the interview.

This disconnect is more than a missed opportunity—it’s a strategic risk. When hiring leaders rely on assumptions instead of structured inquiry, they risk walking away from top-tier talent.

---

1. Start with a Structured Interview Guide

A structured interview guide is a tool that outlines the specific questions aligned to the role’s competencies, responsibilities, and success metrics. It ensures consistency across interviews, reduces bias, and helps hiring teams evaluate candidates on equal footing.

2. Define Success Before You Interview

Clarify what success looks like in the role. What are the must-have skills? What should the new hire accomplish in the first 6–12 months? This clarity informs the questions you ask and helps you focus on what truly matters.

3. Focus on Transferable Skills

Instead of asking narrow, tool-specific questions like “Have you implemented Workday?”, ask broader ones like “Tell me about a time you led the implementation of a new tool or system.” This allows candidates to showcase relevant experience, even if it’s not an exact match.

4. Use Follow-Up Questions to Uncover Depth

Initial answers often only scratch the surface. Follow-up prompts such as:

• “Can you walk me through how you approached that?”

• “What challenges did you face and how did you overcome them?”

• “What would you do differently next time?”

  
  

These questions reveal problem-solving skills, adaptability, and leadership.

5. Don’t Rely on Assumptions

If something is important, ask about it directly. Don’t assume a candidate lacks experience just because they didn’t mention it. For example: “Have you had exposure to change management initiatives? What was your role?”

6. Use Interview Scorecards

Scorecards help hiring teams rate candidates on the same criteria, enabling fair comparisons and reducing bias. They also keep the team aligned on what matters most.

7. Invite Candidates to Share More

End interviews with: “Is there anything we haven’t asked that you think is important for us to know?” This gives candidates the opportunity to highlight relevant experience that may not have surfaced earlier.

---

🌱 Final Thought:

Better hiring starts with better questions. When hiring leaders take the time to prepare, probe, and listen, they unlock the full potential of every candidate. Let’s stop missing out on great talent—and start making smarter, more inclusive hiring decisions.

---

At Integria Consulting, a leading executive search firm in Montreal, we help hiring leaders and recruiters align from day one. Whether you're hiring for a VP HR, COO, or plant manager executive search role, we make sure your recruitment process starts with clarity — and ends with the right leader.